Contact Us

Indoor Environmental Technologies

Toll-free: (866) 446-7717

Tel: (727) 446-7717

Fax: (727) 441-3203

1384 Pierce Street

Clearwater, FL 33756

Comparison between Florida and Federal Govt Corrosive Drywall Guidelines

HUD and CPSC  recently released a document called “Interim Guidance – Identification of Homes with Corrosion from Problem Drywall”.  While this document is similar to the State of Florida Case Definition released in December 2009, there are some differences.  Below is a comparison of the two systems.

State of Florida CPSC/HUD
Criteria 1:
Sentinel Indicators of Drywall Associated Corrosion (Possible Case = all 3)

  1. The home was constructed or renovated with new drywall since 2001.
  2. Observed corrosion of air conditioner evaporator coil exemplified by black corrosion on copper tubing components.  The corrosion can result in refrigerant leakage making it impossible to cool the home requiring coil replacement.  Coil failures indicative of this problem typically occur every 6-14 months
  3. Observed metal corrosion, indicated by blackening of one or more of the following:
    • copper wires, ground wires, and electrical connectors
    • un-insulated and un-coated copper pipes and fittings
    • chrome-plated bathroom fixtures
    • silver and copper jewelry
    • mirror backing in bathrooms
Step 1. Visual inspection must show:(a) Blackening of copper electrical wiring and/or air conditioning evaporator coils; and

(b) The installation of new drywall (for new construction or renovations) between 2001 and 2008.

A positive result for this step (including both criteria) is a prerequisite to any further consideration.

Criteria 2:
Supporting Indicators of Drywall Associated Corrosion (Probable Case = 1 or more)

  1. Observed markings on the back of drywall indicating the country of origin is China.
  2. Objective analysis of drywall in home finds Strontium levels exceed 2,000 mg/kg (ppm), indicating the gypsum used in the drywall was probably mined in China.
  3. If you have met the criteria for “possible case” and answered yes to at least one of the above indicators in Criteria 2, the home meets the criteria for “probable case”.  These criteria do not confirm that the drywall causes corrosion. Identifying the origin of the drywall is considered a screening tool for suspect drywall, but confirmation requires analysis described in Criteria 3.
Step 2: Corroborating EvidenceBecause it is possible that corrosion of metal in homes can occur for other reasons, it is important to obtain additional corroborating evidence of problem drywall. Homes with the characteristic metal corrosion problems must also have at least 2 of these corroborating conditions if the new drywall was installed between 2005 and 2008. For installations between 2001 and 2004, at least 4 of the following conditions must be met. Collecting evidence of these corroborating conditions will in some cases require professional assessors and/or testing by analytical laboratories.

(a) Corrosive conditions in the home, demonstrated by the formation of copper sulfide on copper coupons (test strips of metal) placed in the home for a period of 2 weeks to 30 days or confirmation of thepresence of sulfur in the blackening of the grounding wires and/or air conditioning coils;

(b) Confirmed markings of Chinese origin for drywall in the home;

(c) Strontium levels in samples of drywall core found in the home (i.e. excluding the exterior paper surfaces) exceeding 1200 parts per million (ppm);

(d) Elemental sulfur levels in samples of drywall core found in the home exceeding 10 ppm;

(e) Elevated levels of hydrogen sulfide, carbonyl sulfide and/or carbon disulfide emitted from samples of drywall from the home when placed in test chambers using ASTM Standard Test Method D5504-08 or similar chamber or headspace testing4;

(f) Corrosion of copper metal to form copper sulfide when copper is placed in test chambers with drywall samples taken from the home.

Criteria 3:
Confirmatory Evidence of Drywall Associated Corrosion (Confirmed Case = 1 or more)

  1. Elemental sulfur (Orthorhombic sulfur, cyclooctasulfur, S8) content of gypsum core exceeding 10 mg/kg (ppm), indicating the gypsum in drywall samples from the home contains the source material that is believed to contribute to the reduced sulfur gasses emitted from corrosive drywall. Analytical methods commonly used for this include GC/ECD, GC/MS, or HPLC.
  2. Laboratory analysis of suspect drywall headspace for reduced sulfur gas emissions (H2S, COS, CS2) indicating drywall samples from the home emit reduced sulfur gasses capable of causing copper corrosion. Analytical methods commonly used for this include GC/SCD.6 Results that are indicative of corrosive drywall must be established by each laboratory based upon internal procedures, comparison to control samples, and validated methods.
  3. Qualitative analysis of suspect drywall for its ability to cause corrosion/blackening of copper under controlled conditions, indicating drywall samples from the home emit gasses capable of corroding copper.  Results that are indicative of corrosive drywall must be established by each laboratory based upon internal procedures, comparison to control samples, and validated methods.
Elemental sulfur (Orthorhombic sulfur, cyclooctasulfur, S8) content of gypsum core exceeding 10 mg/kg (ppm) Elemental sulfur levels in samples of drywall core found in the home exceeding 10 ppm
Objective analysis of drywall in home finds Strontium levels exceed 2,000 mg/kg (ppm), indicating the gypsum used in the drywall was probably mined in China. Strontium levels in samples of drywall core found in the home (i.e. excluding the exterior papersurfaces) exceeding 1200 parts per million (ppm);

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!

Leave a Reply

 

 

 

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This site uses KeywordLuv. Enter YourName@YourKeywords in the Name field to take advantage.